Kangaroo Court or Katta Panchayat is Illegal
Katta Panchayat, also known as Kangaroo Court, is an informal and unauthorized system of justice prevalent in some parts of India. These gatherings are typically composed of local leaders or influential people who adjudicate disputes and dispense justice without any legal authority.
Here are a few reasons why Katta Panchayat is considered illegal:
1. Lack of Legal Authority: Katta Panchayats operate outside the formal judicial system, without any legal authority or recognition from the state. Their decisions are not legally binding.
2. Violation of Fundamental Rights: The judgments passed by Katta Panchayats often violate fundamental rights guaranteed by the Indian Constitution, such as the right to equality, right to life and personal liberty, and the right to a fair trial.
3. Arbitrary Decisions: Decisions made by Katta Panchayats are often arbitrary and lack the procedural fairness that is inherent in the formal judicial process. There is usually no formal process of evidence collection, representation, or appeal.
4. Use of Coercion and Violence: Katta Panchayats often use coercion, intimidation, and even violence to enforce their decisions, leading to human rights abuses.
5. Undermining the Rule of Law: By operating outside the formal legal system, Katta Panchayats undermine the rule of law and the authority of the judicial system in India.
Due to these reasons, the Indian judiciary and law enforcement agencies deem Katta Panchayats illegal. Individuals are encouraged to seek justice through the proper legal channels, ensuring that their rights are protected and that justice is administered fairly and transparently.
Obtaining precise statistics on Katta Panchayat cases is challenging because these informal gatherings operate outside the formal judicial system and often go unreported. However, several studies, news reports, and governmental and non-governmental organization (NGO) findings provide some insight into their prevalence and impact. Here are some points based on available information:
Statistics of Katta Panchayat Cases
1. Prevalence: Katta Panchayats are more common in rural and semi-urban areas where access to formal judicial mechanisms may be limited. They are often found in states like Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, and Maharashtra.
2. Types of Cases: These informal courts deal with a variety of issues including property disputes, family conflicts, marital issues, and social code violations. They are particularly notorious for handling "honor" related cases, where they often enforce conservative social norms.
3. Violence and Human Rights Violations: Katta Panchayats are frequently associated with human rights abuses. For example, cases of honor killings, social ostracism, and physical punishment are sometimes linked to their verdicts. Various reports by human rights organizations highlight instances of violence stemming from their judgments.
4. Legal Action and Reforms: While specific statistical data might be scarce, there have been instances where the formal legal system has intervened. Indian courts, including the Supreme Court, have passed judgments condemning the actions of such informal courts and directing state authorities to take action against them.
5. Reports and Studies:
- A 2012 study by the National Commission for Women (NCW) highlighted the prevalence of Khap Panchayats (similar to Katta Panchayats) in North India and their role in honor-related crimes.
- News reports occasionally bring specific cases to light, showcasing the severe punishments and social repercussions decided by these informal courts.
6. Government and NGO Interventions: Various NGOs and governmental bodies work towards educating people about their legal rights and providing access to formal legal mechanisms. These efforts are aimed at reducing reliance on Katta Panchayats.
For more precise and detailed statistics, academic research or reports from human rights organizations operating in India would be necessary. The informal nature of Katta Panchayats makes systematic data collection difficult, but continued efforts by the legal system and civil society aim to reduce their influence and document their impact more comprehensively.
Opinion of Judges about Kangaroo Court or Kattapanchayat
In our opinion, Kattapanchayatdars are nothing but mafia and hooligans, and Kattapanchayat is simply taking the law into one's own hands by some goondas, who unlawfully claim to represent the village.
It may be mentioned that if one wishes to be a leader in the village or urban area, he can contest the elections to the Panchayat or Municipality or other local body constituted by the statutue, but one cannot commit illegal acts like imposition of fine, ex-communication, disconnecting water and electricity supply, threats or acts of violence etc. All these are criminal offences punishable under various provisions of the IPC and other statutes.
In our opinion, Kattapanchayats could not flourish in the first place without the collusion of the Police and other authorities, or by their turning a blind eye to these unlawful activities. If such unlawful, extra constitutional activities are not put down with an iron hand, there will gradually be a collapse of law and order and democracy in the State. Hence we direct all the state authorities to take strong action in accordance with law to put down these unlawful, hooligan activities which have mushroomed in several areas of the State of Tamil Nadu, and institute criminal prosecution against those who are involved.
The Chief Secretary, Home Secretary and Director General of Police, Tamil Nadu are directed to ensure strict compliance of this order. They are also directed to take strong disciplinary action against the administrative and police officials who collude with the Kattapanchayatdars or turn a Nelson's eye to their illegalities and who do not register and prosecute criminal cases against these hooligans. The Chief Secretary will circulate copy of this judgment to all District Magistrates and Superintendents of Police in the State with a letter warning all officials that those who do not comply with the directions in
this judgment will be severely dealt with.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS DATED : 17/3/2016, CORAM, THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE R.SUBBIAH W.P.No.22121 of 2015
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis/index.php/casestatus/viewpdf/271751
https://www.casemine.com/judgement/in/560901b3e4b0149711157497
https://indiankanoon.org/search/?formInput=katta%20panchayat
https://punemirror.com/news/india/apex-court-says-khap-panchayats-are-kangaroo-courts/cid5269236.htm
Astrology Consultation Provided for Relationship Issues Call+91-9611243737, +91-6384762977
- Buy my book Rule of Saintly Kings
- A kingdom, state, or empire must be governed under the instructions of saintly persons and brahmaṇas like the Kumaras. When monarchy ruled throughout the world, the monarch was actually directed by a board of brahmaṇas and saintly persons. The king, as the administrator of the state, executed his duties as a servant of the brahmaṇas. It was not that the kings or brahmaṇas were dictators, nor did they consider themselves proprietors of the state. The kings were also well versed in Vedic literature and thus were familiar with the injunction of Sri isopanisad: isavasyam idaṁ sarvam — everything that exists belongs to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In Bhagavad-gita Lord Kṛṣṇa also claims that He is the proprietor of all planetary systems (Sarva-Loka-maheśvaram). Since this is the case, no one can claim to be the proprietor of the state. The king, president, or head of the state should always remember that he is not the proprietor but the servant.
- https://amzn.to/46axtOR
Comments
Post a Comment